You don’t have to sort it out alone. Our veteran-owned firm helps veterans make this exact choice every day.
Why We Fight for Veterans Through Every Stage of an AMA Appeal
Picking the right review path is hard to do on your own, especially while you’re still dealing with the condition that brought you here.
Veteran-to-Veteran Experience You Can Count On
We are a veteran-owned firm, and our founder, Donald W. Marcari, served as a U.S. Navy JAG attorney. The people reviewing your Supplemental Claim, Higher-Level Review, or Board Appeal know military service and the VA firsthand. You’re not spending the first meeting explaining how deployments, duty stations, and a service record actually work.
Nationwide VA Accreditation, No Travel Required
VA disability benefits fall under federal law, so we represent veterans across the country. You can handle every step with the VA remotely, which means where you live never limits which review option you can pursue. You can send and receive documents and take calls or attend a hearing from home, and any VA exam required for your claim can be scheduled near you.
Donald W. Marcari’s record has also earned recognition as a Virginia Super Lawyer and an AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell, both decided by independent peer review.
Client Testimonials
“Excellent firm if you are needing help with a VA appeal. Very knowledgeable and professional in all matters pertaining to VA law. Highly recommended.” — Brian H.
“Great experience working with this firm. They responded back to all my emails in a timely manner. They worked with me for years until we finally got my claim approved. I highly recommend working with them.” — Andrew S.
How Much Will This Cost?
Nothing!
What Is the Appeals Modernization Act?
The Appeals Modernization Act (AMA) is the federal law that, on February 19, 2019, replaced the VA’s old single-track appeals process. Under that old system, a single appeal could keep moving for years before a veteran got an answer. Instead of one long path through a Notice of Disagreement and the Board, you can now choose among three review lanes: a Supplemental Claim, a Higher-Level Review, or a Board Appeal.
Each lane answers a different question about why you think the VA got your decision wrong. You do not have to try them in a set order, so you pick the one that matches your situation.
If your real issue is a service-connected condition that has gotten worse, that follows a different path, which we cover in our guide on applying for a better rating.
Your Three Ways to Get a VA Decision Reviewed
A Supplemental Claim and a Higher-Level Review are both decided at a VA regional office. A Board Appeal goes to a Veterans Law Judge at the Board of Veterans’ Appeals.
Which lane fits comes down to what went wrong: new evidence the VA never saw, a mistake on the evidence it had, or a case you want a judge to hear. The table below compares all three at a glance.
| Review option? | Can you add new evidence? | Who decides it? | When it fits? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Supplemental Claim (Form 20-0995) | Yes. New and relevant evidence is required to open it. | A reviewer at a VA regional office. VA’s stated goal is an average of about 125 days. | You have new evidence the VA has not seen. |
| Higher-Level Review (Form 20-0996) | No. The record stays closed to what is already on file. | A more senior reviewer at a VA regional office, not the Board. VA’s stated goal is also about 125 days. | You believe the VA erred on the evidence it already had. |
| Board Appeal (Form 10182) | Depends on the docket: no for Direct Review, yes for Evidence Submission or a Hearing. | A Veterans Law Judge at the Board of Veterans’ Appeals. Board review generally takes longer. | You want a judge to decide, especially with a hearing. |
Supplemental Claim (VA Form 20-0995)
A Supplemental Claim reopens your case with new and relevant evidence the VA has not seen, such as a fresh medical opinion or updated records. New means the VA did not have it before, and relevant means it could change the decision. This can be filed on Supplemental Claim form (20-0995).
Higher-Level Review (VA Form 20-0996)
A Higher-Level Review puts your existing file in front of a more senior reviewer, with no new evidence added. You can ask for an informal phone conference to point out where you think the VA went wrong.
If that reviewer finds a clear factual or legal mistake, they can change the decision or send the claim back to fix it. Choose this lane when the facts were already on file and the problem was how the VA read them, using the Higher-Level Review form (20-0996).
Board Appeal (VA Form 10182)
With a Board Appeal, your case goes to a Veterans Law Judge, and you pick one of three dockets:
- Direct Review, which allows no new evidence and no hearing
- Evidence Submission, which lets you add evidence without a hearing
- Hearing, which lets you testify in person before the judge
Direct Review is the quickest of the three when your record is already complete. As a rule, the more you want to add, evidence or testimony, the longer the docket runs.
A board appeal can be filed on the Board Appeal form (10182). Our guide to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals covers dockets and hearings in more detail.
Protect Your Effective Date: The One-Year Window and Continuous Pursuit

Your effective date is the day your benefits start adding up, and it’s worth real money. Once a claim is granted, the VA pays back to that date, not just forward from the decision, so an older effective date can mean years of added back pay.
Three deadlines decide whether you keep it:
- Higher-Level Review or Board Appeal: File within one year of your decision letter to keep your date in place.
- Supplemental Claim: File anytime, but stay inside that same year so your date does not reset.
- Continuous pursuit: File each new review within a year of the last decision to keep the original date alive.
If Your VA Decision Came Before February 19, 2019
If your original decision predates February 19, 2019, you may still be in the older legacy appeals process, the single-track AMA replaced. This is usually where the legacy appeal vs. AMA question comes up.
With a pending Notice of Disagreement, you can opt in to AMA, generally by filing one of the three review forms above after you receive a Statement of the Case or Supplemental Statement of the Case. The legacy process survives only for these older, pending claims. It is not the route for any decision issued today, which always runs through either the Higher-Level Review, Supplemental Claim or Board Appeal.
Talk Through Which VA Appeals Option Fits Your Situation
Choosing between a Supplemental Claim, a Higher-Level Review, and a Board Appeal is hard to get right on your own. We help veterans across the country weigh the evidence, the timeline, and the trade-offs of each lane, then file in time to keep your effective date in place. From there, we prepare your forms and handle the filing so the deadline isn’t on your shoulders.
A free consultation costs you nothing, and our fee is a contingency 20% of retroactive benefits. Call us at 866-866-8387 or fill out our contact form to talk through which review option fits your case.





